Medichecks vs Thriva 2026 — Honest Comparison | TrueVitals
Comparison

Medichecks vs Thriva
Honest Comparison 2026

Medichecks and Thriva are two of the best-known private blood test providers in the UK. Both are legitimate, both use UKAS-accredited labs, and both have their strengths. But they serve different needs, test different depths, and collect blood differently. This comparison covers what each does well, where each falls short, and what both miss — so you can choose the right one for what you actually want to know.

Side by Side

The comparison table

Prices and panels checked on each provider's own website on 16 November 2026. Check before you buy, as prices and offers change.

Medichecks
Thriva
Max biomarkers
59 (Optimal Health)
Membership baseline test 33, from a 48-marker library; one-off kits are smaller
Collection
Finger-prick on many tests; venous at a clinic (+£35) or by a nurse (+£59)
Needle-free Autodraw or finger-prick; nurse venous draw +£60
Entry price
Single markers from £19 (testosterone)
Kits from £65 (PSA); Vitamins £81.90; General Health £117
Comprehensive panel
£199-249 + clinic draw = £234-284 all-in
Membership £360 a year (three tests, doctor video consultations)
Results speed
About 3-4 working days on the big panels, counted from the working day after the lab receives the sample
Thriva aims for 48 hours from the lab receiving the sample
Report style
Individual results with a doctor's comment (included by default)
Doctor-written report in the app (Thriva says practising NHS GPs review results), with trend tracking
Subscription
One-off purchase by default
Kits sold as a subscription you can change, pause or cancel; or the yearly membership
Test catalogue
Large catalogue of individual tests
14 home kits, plus the membership library
Trustpilot
Excellent, 4.5 (2,848 reviews)
Excellent, 4.6 (3,230 reviews)
Lab accreditation
UKAS-accredited laboratory partners
UKAS-accredited partner labs (ISO 15189 / 17025)
Honest Verdicts

Where each provider wins — and where they don't

Choose Medichecks if:

You want a large catalogue of individual tests. You want a one-off test without subscription pressure. You want the option of a venous blood draw for more accurate results. You want a specific marker tested that smaller providers don't offer. You're comfortable with finger-prick collection or willing to pay extra for venous.

The trade-off:

Their most comprehensive panel tops out at 59 biomarkers. A venous draw adds £35 at a clinic or £59 for a nurse on the big panels. Results come with a doctor's comment rather than a written report that reads the markers together.

Choose Thriva if:

You want regular testing: kits on a subscription, or a membership with three tests a year, a doctor and video consultations. You prefer an app-based experience with visual trend tracking. You want a simple, focused package without a huge catalogue to navigate. The needle-free Autodraw device is easier than a finger-prick for many people. You value a clean user experience over testing depth.

The trade-off:

The membership baseline test is 33 markers and its whole library is 48 blood markers. A venous draw is a paid extra (£60 for a nurse). Subscription model means ongoing commitment. Smaller sample volume limits which markers can be reliably tested. Beyond a separate PSA kit (£65), we did not find tumour markers, cortisol or coeliac screening on its menu.

The Gap

What neither Medichecks nor Thriva puts in its main panels

Both providers cover the fundamentals well: thyroid (TSH, Free T4), cholesterol, liver, kidney, iron, B12, vitamin D, basic hormones. But neither puts the depth needed for comprehensive health screening into one panel. These are missing from both providers' main panels (some are sold as separate tests):

Tumour markers — CEA, CA 19-9, PSA, CA-125, CA 15-3 (both sell PSA as a separate test)

Immunoglobulins — IgG, IgM, IgA, IgE

Coeliac screen — anti-tTG (Coeliac UK says only 36% of people with coeliac disease are diagnosed)

Fasting insulin + HOMA-IR — can show insulin resistance before HbA1c rises

Cystatin C — kidney function that muscle mass and creatine don't distort (in Thriva's library for follow-up tests, not its baseline)

Rheumatoid factor — autoimmune screening

These aren't obscure markers. Fasting insulin can show insulin resistance while HbA1c is still normal, and Coeliac UK says only 36% of people with coeliac disease have been diagnosed. These are gaps that matter.

The Third Option

If you want more depth than either provides

If 33 to 59 biomarkers is enough for your needs, Medichecks and Thriva both serve that market well. If you want deeper testing — everything above plus cross-system analysis and clinician review — the TrueVitals Ultimate panel tests 140 biomarkers (139 for women) for £399 with the venous blood draw included at 103 partner clinics, or £29 extra at home.

Medichecks

59

biomarkers

Thriva

33

biomarkers (membership baseline)

TrueVitals

140

biomarkers

TrueVitals Ultimate: £399 all-in, phlebotomy included. Professional venous draw at 103 partner clinics or at home for £29. Clinician-reviewed cross-system report. Results within 4 working days of your blood draw. No subscription. Full comparison of all UK providers.

Common Questions

Frequently asked questions

Is Medichecks or Thriva better?
Medichecks for one-off testing with the widest catalogue and venous draw option. Thriva for regular testing on a subscription or membership, with a clean app. Medichecks' largest panel is 59 biomarkers and Thriva's membership baseline is 33. For deeper testing, TrueVitals (140 markers) or Lola Health (70 markers) offer more. Full provider comparison.
How many biomarkers do they test?
Medichecks: 59 on its largest panel (Optimal Health). Thriva: the membership baseline test is 33 markers, from a 48-marker library; its one-off kits are smaller. Both cover thyroid, cholesterol, liver, kidney, iron, vitamins, and basic hormones. Medichecks' largest panel includes ApoB and Lp(a), but neither puts tumour markers, immunoglobulins, coeliac screening, cystatin C or HOMA-IR in its main panels. Most comprehensive blood test UK.
Do they use finger-prick or venous draw?
Medichecks uses finger-prick on many tests; its big panels are venous (+£35 clinic, +£59 nurse). Thriva uses its needle-free Autodraw device or a finger-prick, with a nurse draw for £60. Neither includes venous phlebotomy in the panel price. Capillary samples (finger-prick or an upper-arm device) are small, fail more often than a venous draw, and limit which markers can be run. Is private testing worth it?
How much do they cost?
Medichecks: up to £249 plus £35-59 for a venous draw on the big panels (£234-308 all-in). Thriva: one-off kits from £65 (PSA) to £211.50 (Sports performance), for example General Health £117, or the membership at £360 a year for three tests. Prices change, and Medichecks runs regular offers. Verify at each provider's website. Full pricing guide.
Is there a more comprehensive option?
Yes. TrueVitals Ultimate tests 140 biomarkers (139 for women) for £399 with the venous blood draw included. It covers almost every marker in Medichecks' and Thriva's main panels (not active B12 or UIBC) plus tumour markers, immunoglobulins, coeliac screening, HOMA-IR and cystatin C, with a clinician-reviewed cross-system report within 4 working days of the blood draw. Best blood test UK guide.

Want more than 59 biomarkers?

140 biomarkers. Clinician-reviewed cross-system reporting. Professional venous draw included at 103 partner clinics. Results within 4 working days of your blood draw. No subscription.